Photo Credit: Getty Images

Okay so we have all heard that Hilary Duff and her husband Mike Comrie split up in January after being married for 3 years... buuuut we also have seen them together lately! Like, a lot. The last spotting of the pair was this weekend at Coachella, where they were very much so together. So are they back together?? Are they just friends?? Are we all crazy for caring?! Here are my theories:

1. They never really broke up - I know what a lot of you are thinking, "You're crazy! Why would they announce breaking up if they didn't actually break up!" Well, they have gotten a LOT of attention and publicity since announcing the split, so maybe it was a way of promoting Hilary and the new music she's been working on?? I mean listen, I've broken up with people and I have NEVER been that friendly with any of them even when we were totally cool! You don't really just go to Coachella with an ex...

2. Hilary is feeling like trying again with her marriage now that her sister got engaged - So maybe its possible they DID break up for a while, but then when Haylie became engaged, Hilary and Mike were encouraged to try again! Sources are saying the couple is still broken up... but I just don't believe that! Its very possible they got back together, I mean they were married and have a son so it wouldn't be surprising for them to get back together!!!

3. I'm just really hopeful for them - This is the one I'm really hoping is not true! Because maybe I'm just crazy and think they're a great couple who belong together, OKAY. I mean, look at them! They're so cute! And their son is adorable! THEY SHOULD BE TOGETHER. Hilary and Mike, if you're reading this, I'm rooting for you to be able to work things out.

Hilary also shared this photo on Instagram yesterday... think it has anything to do with her relationship with Mike?? 

Let me know your theories on Facebook!!